Glossary term
Reality testing
Also called: reality check, testing assumptions
By the DivorceMediators editorial team · Last updated November 12, 2026
Definition
Reality testing is a mediator technique of asking a party questions that help them check whether their expectations, their alternatives to agreement, or a proposed term are realistic and workable. The mediator raises the questions; the party reaches their own conclusions.
In plain language
People often go into a negotiation sure that their fallback is strong: “If we don’t agree, a judge will give me the house.” Reality testing asks them to look at that belief more closely, usually in private.
An essay on the University of Colorado’s conflict-studies site describes reality testing as asking hard questions about each party’s power and options, so that a party who is refusing a deal because of an unrealistic alternative can see it more clearly. Typical questions: What will you do if we don’t agree? What will that cost, and how long will it take? Who do you think would win, and why? Has anyone outside looked at your assumptions?
It also applies to proposed agreements. Will this schedule still work when the children change schools? Can each of you afford these payments next year?
Reality testing has to stay neutral. A Colorado bar report on mediation and the practice of law lists asking questions to reality-test a party’s expectations, including their best or worst alternative to agreement, among things a mediator may do without giving legal advice. But predicting how a court will rule, when lawyers are not present, is advice the report says a mediator should not give.
How it differs from
- Evaluative mediation: the mediator gives their own assessment. In reality testing the mediator asks; the party evaluates.
- Legal information vs. legal advice: questions about a party’s assumptions are usually information-neutral; telling them the likely court result can be advice.
- Pressure to settle: the standards forbid it. Reality testing should help a party decide, not push them toward yes.
Example
In a private session, a spouse says he will refuse any deal and “let the court sort it out.” The mediator asks how long he expects that to take, what it would cost, what happens to the children’s schedule in the meantime, and whether his lawyer has reviewed his expectations. He decides to talk with his lawyer before the next session.
Varies by state
Reality testing is a practice, not a legal term. How far a mediator may go in discussing likely outcomes depends on the state’s rules on mediator opinions and on the practice of law.
Related terms
Sources
- Brad Spangler, “Reality Testing” (2003), Beyond Intractability, Conflict Information Consortium, University of Colorado Boulder: https://www.beyondintractability.org/essay/reality_testing
- Colorado Bar Association, Alternative Dispute Resolution Section, Recommended Guidelines Regarding Unauthorized Practice of Law Issues in Mediation (approved January 12, 2007), copy hosted by the Colorado Judicial Branch: https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/sites/default/files/2025-08/Unauthorized%20Practice%20of%20Law%20and%20Mediation.doc%20accessible%202025.pdf (section IV.B.2).
- Association of Family and Conciliation Courts (AFCC), Model Standards for Family and Divorce Mediation (2025 revision; developed by an AFCC and ABA Family Law Section task force; adopted by the ABA Section of Dispute Resolution, ACR and APFM). Read in the copy hosted by the Supreme Court of Ohio: https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/docs/JCS/disputeResolution/resources/mediation/family/ModelStandardsFamilyDivorce.pdf (Standard I.E).
General information about mediation terms, not legal advice. Rules differ by state and by court.