Glossary term
Evaluative mediation
By the DivorceMediators editorial team · Last updated November 12, 2026
Definition
Evaluative mediation is an approach in which the mediator, in addition to managing the negotiation, offers an assessment of the issues, such as the strengths and weaknesses of each side’s position or how a court might view them. The parties remain free to accept or reject the assessment and still decide the outcome themselves.
In plain language
An evaluative mediator does more than keep the conversation going. Drawing on subject-matter experience, the mediator may say what they think of a proposal, point out a weak argument, or describe the range of results they would expect if the dispute went to a judge. The aim is to give the parties a realistic reference point.
The idea of a neutral who evaluates is familiar in court rules. Minnesota’s rule describes evaluative processes, such as early neutral evaluation, in which neutrals with experience in the subject may assess the strengths and weaknesses of claims. The comment to Washington’s rule on lawyer-neutrals observes that a third-party neutral may serve “primarily as a facilitator, evaluator or decision maker” depending on the process.
Evaluation sits close to two ethical lines. Standards for mediators say the mediator shall never pressure parties to settle, and the family-mediation standards say the mediator shall not provide legal advice. A Colorado bar guideline warns that, when the parties’ lawyers are not present, a mediator’s prediction of how a court would resolve an issue amounts to giving legal advice. An evaluative style is therefore most common where the parties have their own lawyers in the room.
How it differs from
- Facilitative mediation: no opinion on the merits from the mediator.
- Early neutral evaluation: a separate process whose purpose is the evaluation itself.
- Arbitration: the arbitrator’s view is a decision. An evaluative mediator’s view is information.
- Settlement conference with a judge: a judicial officer, not a private neutral, gives the view.
Example
Two spouses, each with a lawyer present, disagree about whether an inheritance is shared property. The mediator, a retired family-law practitioner, tells both sides how she sees the argument and where she thinks each is exposed. They use that view to narrow the gap and then negotiate the rest themselves.
Varies by state
What a mediator may say about likely legal outcomes, and whether a non-lawyer mediator may say anything of the kind, is governed by each state’s rules on the practice of law and by program rules. Some court programs prohibit their mediators from evaluating; others offer evaluative processes under a different name.
Sources
- Minnesota General Rules of Practice for the District Courts, Rule 114 (Alternative Dispute Resolution): https://www.revisor.mn.gov/court_rules/gp/id/114/ (Rule 114.02).
- Washington Rules of Professional Conduct, RPC 2.4 (Lawyer Serving as Third-Party Neutral) and comments: https://www.courts.wa.gov/court_rules/pdf/RPC/GA_RPC_02_04_00.pdf (comment 1).
- Colorado Bar Association, Alternative Dispute Resolution Section, Recommended Guidelines Regarding Unauthorized Practice of Law Issues in Mediation (approved January 12, 2007), copy hosted by the Colorado Judicial Branch: https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/sites/default/files/2025-08/Unauthorized%20Practice%20of%20Law%20and%20Mediation.doc%20accessible%202025.pdf
- Association of Family and Conciliation Courts (AFCC), Model Standards for Family and Divorce Mediation (2025 revision; developed by an AFCC and ABA Family Law Section task force; adopted by the ABA Section of Dispute Resolution, ACR and APFM). Read in the copy hosted by the Supreme Court of Ohio: https://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/docs/JCS/disputeResolution/resources/mediation/family/ModelStandardsFamilyDivorce.pdf (Standards I.E and II.B).
- Leonard L. Riskin, “Understanding Mediators’ Orientations, Strategies, and Techniques: A Grid for the Perplexed,” 1 Harv. Negot. L. Rev. 7 (1996). Only the citation and abstract page were opened (University of Florida Levin College of Law repository): https://scholarship.law.ufl.edu/facultypub/668/
General information about mediation terms, not legal advice. Rules differ by state and by court.